Why It Is Healthy to Have your Faith Challenged in College

By

This is a guest post by Jessica McMann. She is is a freelance writer trying to change the world one step at a time through blogging about things that matter to her. Find some of her work over at christiancolleges.com.

If you would like to write a guest post for this blog, check out the guidelines here.

College is often portrayed as a life-changing experience, and rightly so. Some of the most formative experiences of a person’s young life can occur during those few years on a university campus. In college it isn’t at all uncommon that a student might realize their career ambitions, meet a lifelong friend or date their future spouse.

Religion is one of the potential formative experiences in college that doesn’t get as much attention. Specifically, it’s far less common to hear about how a student who finds their way to or from Christianity, Islam, or Judaism (or even Atheism for that matter) while attending a university.Taking classes and sharing experiences alongside classmates from varying backgrounds can cause even the most religious or nonreligious person to inspect, analyze, and even question their beliefs.

question your faith

I can personally attest that the college experience can mark a watershed moment for Christians who have had little exposure to other religions and belief systems. It can be a jarring experience to engage people who disagree or take issue with one’s faith, but it can also produce a healthy dialogue on the subject. The purpose of this post is to encourage Christians in college to have that dialogue with believers and nonbelievers.

Welcome the Challenge

I think it’s important that Christian college students welcome the challenge of discussing their faith to others, particularly to people who hold opposing views. Why would I advocate a conversation that so rarely changes minds on either side? Well, I think more (young) people could stand to take time to understand views that aren’t their own, Christians included. When I was in college, it was all too often that I overheard one of my friends generalize about a particular person’s beliefs just because they weren’t their own. It’s not just Atheists and Agnostics who paint faith with a broad brush; it’s all too common of a problem within Christianity itself.

College students participating in such a debate might still feel the same way about their opinions, but they might also gain a deeper understanding about those held by the other person. Sounds reasonable enough, right?

Asking the Hard Questions

napkin religionI believe in asking hard questions, particularly when it comes to matters of faith. If I’m having a hard day, if the world suddenly ceases to make any sense to me, if the news headlines are too grim to bear, I don’t slink away from asking, “Why?” If anything, asking the hard questions of yourself and your faith is instrumental in coming to understand the power of prayer and God’s plan for all of us.

Refusing to shy away from these hard questions is an extremely healthy exercise in strengthening a student’s faith. Say that a Christian student participates in a debate on religion and they’re asked to consider some of the common critiques against the faith. Is it better for that student to ignore and repel questions calling their faith in question or to address them head on, even if the answer isn’t pretty? I fear that students who ignore hard questions run the risk of letting them fester in their mind unanswered. It’s better to face and reason with any doubts—faith is always stronger for the earnest struggle.

Consult Like-minded Students

Above all, I think it’s critical that college students—particular Christians—seek out a welcoming community of like-minded peers to serve as a support structure. College can be a lot of fun, but it can also demoralize and decenter even the most devout and focused students. The best way to counter that spiritual fatigue is to seek solace from those who’ve been there before and understand what you’re going through.


The newsletter includes a weekly blog digest
and the monthly newsletter with exclusive news and offers. This month's offer is a
free copy of my eBook
The Skeleton Church.


How Frequently Do You Want to Receive Blog Posts?
Daily Blog Posts
Weekly Post Summary
BOTH Daily Posts AND Weekly Summary

  • Sam

    Attending a Christian college and seminary had unintended consequences for me. I was exposed to excellent professors and a wealth of reading material, especially in the fields of theology, church history, psych, Bible, and languages. I discovered that much of what I had been taught, especially about the Bible, theology and church was not quite right.

    Neither this nor challenges from non-believers challenged my faith. But they did challenge what I like to think of as “the party line” AKA the somewhat “official” position of that part of the church with which I had a relationship. My professors pretended they had no idea that those of us who actually read the assignments in those dusty tomes of yesteryear might slowly come to realize that so much of what we had previously thought to be the truth was rather a huge pile of (ignorance).

    • http://www.tillhecomes.org/ Jeremy Myers

      This was similar to my experience as well. I appreciate my time in seminary and Bible college, but have had to filter much of what I was taught. I am not sure, however, that without the Bible college and seminary, I would be able to filter. So it’s a Catch-22.

  • strawtree

    I’m going to home-college my kids. :)

    • http://www.tillhecomes.org/ Jeremy Myers

      Ha! Is this an option? We have enough trouble with home-schooling grade school kids.